Showing posts with label Agrifos. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Agrifos. Show all posts

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Part 11: Air Products Wacky Misadventure

EPA contends Air Products has violated RCRA because they were sending their sulfuric acid back to the company they purchased it from.

That company - Agrifos - used the sulfuric acid to make fertilizer which they sold.

EPA contends the used sulfuric acid is "spent."

Spent sulfuric acid that is being recycled is a solid waste.

The spent sulfuric acid, because it has a pH < 2 is a hazardous waste - D002.

The spent sulfuric acid also contains 2,4-DNT above 0.13 mg/L which also makes it a hazardous waste - D030.

Air Products did not see it that way, contending: "[it] was a product that was purposefully produced since the inception of its Facility and that this product was not a solid waste or a hazardous waste."

EPA is correct based on the following:
  1. The sulfuric acid was used and as a result of contamination could no longer serve the purpose for which it was produced without processing.  This made it meet the definition of "spent."
  2. The "spent" sulfuric acid was being recycled as an ingredient in another process (Agrifos)
  3. The recycling involved producing a fertilizer.
  4. The fertilizer is designed to be placed on the ground.
  5. Because the spent sulfuric acid was used to produce products that are applied to or placed on the land, this meets the definition of "used in a manner constituting disposal."
  6. A "spent" material that will be "used in a manner constituting disposal" meets the definition of a solid waste.
  7. Air Products did not make a hazardous waste determination or use an exclusion.
  8. Because a solid waste was generated, the pH and 2,4-DNT parameters will make it a hazardous waste.
Moral of the story:

It's all about meeting or not meeting the definition of solid waste.  What you think sounds logical or reasonable or is sound has nothing to do with the process.  Once it meets the definition you are stuck there unless you can find an exclusion.  Once it becomes a solid waste then you must make a hazardous waste determination.  Based on that, you can then determine how and where it will be managed. 


This horse has now been beat to a pulp and can be discarded.  Hmmm, I wonder if it meets a hazardous waste definition?


.

Saturday, September 11, 2010

Part 9: Part 266, Subpart C - Use Constituting Disposal

For the last eight posts we have delved into how the EPA came up with their allegation that Air Products' sulfuric acid was "spent" and a "hazardous waste."  Based on this designation, the EPA was able to file a complaint that there was a violation of RCRA that had taken place.

All of this was brought about by Air Products' failure to see their used sulfuric acid as meeting the definition of a solid waste.  Now looking at this from afar, one might reasonably conclude that it's not worth the potential fine to recycle anything that does not have a clearly defined exemption.  Someone else might look at this situation and get upset at how inflexible EPA is and that they tie the hands of a generator looking for an environmentally sound and economically beneficial means to manage a production process.

Like I said in my last post, you need to see it from a regulator's view point.  One thing that the EPA knew to be true, is that taking something and putting it on the ground could pose a much more significant public health or environmental concern then if you had disposed of it at a permitted hazardous waste facility.

When the EPA makes a regulation they have to think about what that something could be.  Using it, treating it, reclaiming it - all pose some additional risk.  But that risk is minimal compared to what happens if you place it on the ground.  Unfortunately regulations are difficult to write that can differentiate between what is OK and what is bad, so the EPA uses what are known as "loop holes" .....err....I mean "exclusions."

Exclusions attempt to address situations where the rule punishes sound environmental management techniques in an effort to prevent the regulated community from getting around the goal of the law.  Which, if you have forgotten, is to protect public health and the environment from the mismanagement of hazardous waste.

So for Air Products an exclusion was available for them that they could have looked into.  It was overlooked simply because they never went into the land of RCRA.  Jumping down the rabbit hole requires that you discard the material creating a solid waste.  Had they done that, they may have been able to exclude the sulfuric acid from being classified as a hazardous waste by managing under a different standard - Part 266, Subpart C - Use Constituting Disposal.  According to the EPA:
Part 266, Subpart C, regulates recyclable materials that are placed on the land either directly or after mixing with other materials. This type of reuse of a recyclable material is regulated as land treatment or landfilling when the material being applied to the land is a hazardous waste or contains a hazardous waste. The Agency regulates the placement of hazardous secondary materials on the land due to the similarity of this practice to simple land disposal.
In Air Products' case, because the sulfuric acid met the definition of a hazardous waste, any recycling that involved placing it on the ground would require the same degree of treatment as that required to go into a hazardous waste landfill.  There are a few conditions placed on materials - called "commercial hazardous waste-derived products" that are to be managed under Part 266 Subpart C:
  1. They are made for the general public's use;
  2. They have undergone a chemical reaction so as to be inseparable by physical means; and
  3. They meet applicable Part 268 land disposal restrictions treatment standards.
All of these three conditions could have most likely been met, however, it was not Air Products sulfuric acid that had to meet them but the fertilizer produced by Agrifos.  Recycling in this manner must be a partnership between the generator and the producer of the commercial hazardous waste-derived product.

Here's the rub.  If, the producer does not keep their end of the bargain (the three conditions described previously), the exclusion was not met and the spent secondary material (e.g. sulfuric acid) goes back to being a hazardous waste.  This is the same sort of situation that befell Air Products.  Once deemed a hazardous waste, all the hazardous waste management stuff that wasn't done - because you thought it exempt - presents a situation where the EPA can rightly declare it as "mismanagement."

There is one bit of difference in the two situations in that materials destined to be managed under Part 266 Subpart C are fully regulated as hazardous waste prior to them being used.  So had Air Products lived up to their end, the mismanagement involving storage would not have happened.

Part 266 provides a special case for fertilizers that contain recyclable materials, these products are not subject to regulation provided they meet the applicable treatment standards in subpart D of Part 268 for each hazardous waste that they contain.

If Air Products had gone this route, EPA would have had little say in the matter provided Agrifos was living up to its end of the requirements, Air Products met all the 262 and 263 applicable regulations, and the 2,4-DNT would not leach out of the fertilizer at greater than 140 mg/kg as per the 268.48 Universal Treatment Standards.

OK, so not a walk in the park, but not a deal breaker either.  The point of all of this is to show how important it is to know what will happen to the material all the way to the end.  There are a lot of areas where things can get messed up, especially when you have to rely on someone else in the management process.  But that's no different than putting it on a manifest and sending it to a TSDF.  If they don't manage the waste properly it was your waste and you get stuck with the liability.

Now you may be saying to yourself heck with it, I'll just dump it down the drain and be rid of it!

Not a bad idea...and it's legal too!

Next Post: POTWs, domestic sewage, and your waste.  An almost perfect mix.


.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Part 7: Materials that are not solid waste when recycled

It seems pretty cut and dry now that EPA was correct in their allegation that Air Products "violated the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act [when it] sent spent sulfuric acid, a hazardous waste, to the nearby phosphoric acid facility owned by Agrifos Fertilizer, Inc."

After reading all the previous six posts, the evidence points to the fact that Air Products generated a spent material which was recycled in a manner constituting disposal.  This act, from generation to sending it to Agrifos caused the sulfuric acid to meet the EPA's definition of discarded.  And when a material is discarded it becomes a solid waste.  And because it is both corrosive (D002)  and contains 2,4-DNT (D030), it meets the definition of a hazardous waste as well.

But there is one more possibility that a sharp reader familiar with 40 CFR 261.2 might offer as a way out of this solid waste/hazardous waste quagmire;  Doesn't 261.2(e) give an exemption of sorts for certain recycling activities?

Why yes it does.  It's called materials that are not solid waste when recycled and was designed to make recycling available to generators without making them go down the solid waste/hazardous waste path.

Remember, if it doesn't meet the definition of a solid waste it cannot become a hazardous waste regardless of how hazardous or dangerous the material may be.

So EPA brings in three more questions to ask regarding the recycling method:
  1. Will it be used or reused as ingredients in an industrial process to make a product; or
  2. Will it be used or reused as effective substitutes for commercial products; or
  3. Will it be returned to the original process from which they are generated
Well that looks pretty dang awesome!  Why didn't Air Products use either No. 1 or No. 2 in their defense?

Well you know that old adage about the Lord giveth and he taketh away?  Well same thing is in play here as well.  You see, all three of those methods kick you out of meeting the definition of discarded which is what's needed to make your stuff a solid waste.  Simply put, if you recycle by any of those three methods your material is - as the title states - not solid waste when recycled.

Unless......
  • The material is being reclaimed before reusing it; or
  • The material is used in a manner constituting disposal or used to produce products that are applied to the land; or
  • The material is burned for energy recovery, used to produce a fuel, or contained in fuels; or
  • the material is accumulated speculatively;

Doh!

Notice a theme here?  Remember this thinking goes back 30 years or more.  EPA was concerned about materials ending up in the ground where they could contaminate drinking water supplies, put into the air where they could be inhaled, handled by untrained personnel where they could be mismanaged, or stored for long periods of time where they could leak or catch fire or impact the public.

If you could recycle it without doing that, EPA said go for it.  In the case of Air Products' sulfuric acid, because the end result was the production of a fertilizer that was designed to be "applied to the land," 261.2(e) does not apply.

Next post: EPA feels your pain.


.

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Part 6: The how it is recycled is the key

In my last post we (hopefully) decided on two things regarding Air Products' used sulfuric acid.
  1. It meets the EPA definition of being recycled 
  2. It meets the EPA definition of spent
The EPA in their Consent Decree "alleges that Air Products...from at least 1990 until September 4, 2009, sent spent sulfuric acid, a hazardous waste, to the nearby phosphoric acid facility owned by Agrifos Fertilizer, Inc."  Whether or not it's a hazardous waste as the EPA alleges, depends on if the spent sulfuric acid meets the definition of a solid waste, which Air Products maintains "it is not."

Now it may seem that after five lengthy posts I could have gotten to this point quicker and that all I am doing is whipping a dead horse.  Maybe so, but I have seen this mistake over and over again and it is based almost always on a misunderstanding of when a material becomes a solid waste.

So had Air Products made the determination that the sulfuric acid was spent would it have changed anything?  Probably not, simply because they never viewed the sulfuric acid as anything other than a usable product.  So when faced with a similar situation, what do you do?  Again...forget what you think and concentrate on meeting the definitions.  If you meet them you are...if you do not - you are off the hook at least with RCRA.

Because Air Products was sending the spent sulfuric acid to Agrifos, this constituted recycling.  Since they are the ones doing the recycling, we need to ask how it is going to be recycled by them.  This is where the information needed to be asked usually comes to an abrupt halt.  When you don't look at the how and assume it's product and really none of your business how they use it, you skip over the four questions that will determine if it meets the definition of discarded, which if you remember, is the criteria necessary to make a solid waste determination.  

When a material is designated as spent - and - it is destined to be recycled, four additional questions must then be asked:
  1. Will the spent material be burned to recover energy, used to produce a fuel or are otherwise contained in fuels?
  2. Will the spent material be Reclaimed? 
  3. Will the spent material be accumulated speculatively?  Can you show that the spent material is potentially recyclable and has a feasible means of being recycled - and - that during the calendar year the amount recycled equals at least 75 percent?
  4. Will the spent material be applied to or placed on the land in a manner that constitutes disposal, or used to produce products that are applied to or placed on the land or are otherwise contained in products that are applied to or placed on the land?
In the case of Air Products' sulfuric acid:
  • Is it spent?  Yes
  • Will it be recycled?  Yes
  • Will the recycling produce a product that is to be applied or placed on the ground?  Yes...the fertilizer produced by Agrifos!
Now looking at Table 1 form 40 CFR 261.2....


...you will notice that Spent Materials has an (*) in each of the four columns indicating that if it is a spent material AND recycled in one of the three ways or accumulated speculatively, it is a solid waste.

So what we now know about Air Product's sulfuric acid is this:
It is spent and it is a solid waste.
Which means the EPA was correct in their allegation. Unless.........

Next Post: Materials that are not solid waste when recycled.


.

Sunday, September 5, 2010

Part 3: I didn't think I was discarding when I call it a product...

In my last post, I asked the question - did Air Products err when they claimed their used sulfuric acid was a “product that was purposefully produced since inception of its facility and that this product was not a solid waste?”

Let me ask another question.  If some other company set out to make a product that consisted of sulfuric acid and just a smidge of 2,4-DNT.  Let’s also say that there is a market for this particular product.  Now If you compared the two products together and you found that there was no difference in chemical makeup, potency, or usefulness, would you say that the two products are identical?

If you said “yes” then you are not ready to jump down the rabbit hole with Alice and partake in the many wacky adventures in RCRA-Land.  They are the same but not the same because the sulfuric acid containing a smidge of 2,4-DNT produced by Air Products will, unfortunately, be found to meet the EPA definition of “discarded.”

As I said in my last post, it has nothing to do with the chemical and everything to do with the definition.  So now it comes down to how does the EPA define discarded?  Remember also, that to become a hazardous waste you must first meet the definition of a solid waste, which according to the law – called RCRA – means:
any garbage, refuse, sludge, and other discarded material.......
So there you have it “any” and “discarded.”  So in black and white terms, anything that is discarded is a solid waste.  There can really be no discussion on what “any” means, so what needs to be figured out is how “discarded” is defined.  It is at this point - just like with the word “waste” - that you need to forget about what you think discarded means and accept what EPA has - through lots of discussion and public commenting - decided it means.

In Air Products situation with their used sulfuric acid it works like this:
  • Is the used sulfuric acid going to be abandoned by being placed directly onto or into the land?  No
  • Is the used sulfuric acid going to be abandoned by being placed directly onto or into the water?  No
  • Is the used sulfuric acid going to be abandoned by being burned or incinerated?  No
  • Is the used sulfuric acid going to be abandoned by Accumulating, storing, or treating (but not recycling) it before or in lieu of being abandoned by being placed onto the land or into the water, burned, or incinerated?   No
  • Is the sulfuric acid a military munitions?  Nope
  • Is the used sulfuric acid a dioxin containing waste stream identified by the EPA in 40 CFR 262.31 with the EPA Waste Number F022, F023, F026, and F028?  Ahhhh…..No
  • Is the used sulfuric acid being fed to a halogen acid furnace?  No on that as well.
  • Is the used sulfuric acid being recycled by being used or reused as an ingredient or intermediate in an industrial process to make a product.  Another way to ask this question: did the used sulfuric acid come from one process and is it going to be used as feedstock in another process? Yes
At this point, Air Products’ used sulfuric acid that is being sent to Agrifos for their use in making a fertilizer meets the EPA definition of “recycled.”  And when recycled as described in 261.2(c) would meet the definition of “discarded” - which is the criteria necessary to become a solid waste - which then makes the used sulfuric acid susceptible to being classified as a hazardous waste.

So did Air Products open Pandora’s box o’ RCRA fun when they decided that their used sulfuric acid was a “product that was purposefully produced since inception of its facility” to be sent to Agrifos for their use to make a fertilizer?  So far what we know is this.  Air Products’ used sulfuric acid meets the EPA definition of recycled.

Find out what happens when the next exciting not-even-close-to-a-conclusion post on making a solid waste determination continues.

Am I dragging this out?  Well you can be the judge of that.  Here’s my response though.  It is complex and confusing and when you jump down the rabbit hole you need to do it with the understanding of being correct.  Otherwise a $1.5 million dollar fine could be in your future - not because you made a mistake - but because you assumed you understood the process.  Keep reading and we will get there.  I promise.

Next post: When does recycling make a solid waste?

.

Saturday, September 4, 2010

Part 2: Waste is not in the eye of the beholder

The biggest single issue leading to what was characterized by the EPA as a “mismanagement of hazardous waste” by Air Products and their used sulfuric acid surrounds the word “waste” itself.

Waste denotes something that has no value.  In the business world, waste denotes something different, that is, a cost to the bottom-line.  Now when coupled together, the idea of “no value” and “cost” it becomes easy to see how a business like Air Products could come to see the sulfuric acid they had used in a process as something other than a waste, especially since their neighbor, Agrifos, could utilize this acid in making one of their products.

From a business perspective, this made perfect sense.  Agrifos wanted the acid making it have value, and in so doing, reduced Air Products cost for managing it.  Win, win!  Now the issue could be made that the used sulfuric acid posed an increase risk to public health or the environment, but that issue was never raised by the EPA or the state of Texas.  Like I said in my last post, there is no fundamental difference in hazard or property between Air Products’ used sulfuric acid and new sulfuric acid used to make the fertilizer. It was not Air Product’s sulfuric acid that was at issue, it was the use of acids at “high risk mineral processing facilities” such as Agrifos.

So why go after Air Products?  That’s a question for a different type of blog.  This blog is all about the process.  Regardless of the why, the question remains, did Air Products err when they claimed their used sulfuric acid was a “product that was purposefully produced since inception of its facility and that this product was not a solid waste?”

There is a difference between making a product out of chemicals and making a product out of chemicals used to make a product.  It is not the chemical, the characteristics, or the hazard to health or the environment that comes into play.  What determines when - or if - a material is a hazardous waste comes down first to when the definition of a solid waste is met.

And there’s that word “waste” again.  It is at this point that you need to forget about what you understand waste to mean and settle into accepting what RCRA has to say about it.

  • The term ‘‘hazardous waste’’ means a solid waste, or combination of solid wastes......
  • The term ‘‘solid waste’’ means any garbage, refuse, sludge, and other discarded material.......

First and foremost, to become a hazardous waste you must first become a solid waste- or - looking at it from a different angle - if you meet the definition of a solid waste you could also meet the definition of a hazardous waste.

So the question must always focus on did I meet the definition of a solid waste?  If you can keep it out of that definition then the identification as a hazardous waste can never be met, regardless of how hazardous or dangerous it is.  As I tell my students - it’s not about hazard it’s all about definition.

So there is Air Products with this acid that they used to make the polyurethane and hydrogen gas products they sell.  And it is at this point that a solid waste Determination must be made – regardless of any potential value, recycling, cost savings, prudency, or environmental soundness that may be applicable.  Does the sulfuric acid that was used to make a product meet the definition of a solid waste?

  • Is it garbage?   No
  • Is it refuse?   No
  • Is it a sludge? No
  • Is it being discarded?  Ahhh…what does that mean?
That’s a good question, for when Congress gave the EPA their definition of a solid waste, they did not give them a definition for “discarded.”  So EPA defined what the term "discarded" would mean.  So once something is discarded according to the EPA it becomes a solid waste, and then all the fun begins.

Next post: Discarded means exactly what EPA says it does.

.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Part 1: You say product, they say waste

An interesting court case came to my attention today and it got me thinking about how critical the solid waste determination step is.  A company, Air Products, purchased sulfuric acid from another company, Agrifos, and used that sulfuric acid in one of their manufacturing process.  Air Products then gave the used sulfuric acid back to Agrifos where it was used to make fertilizer.  On the surface, most folks would say "And what's wrong with that?  It's not a waste if it's still usable, besides...isn't that recycling?"

Well that's the problem.  What looks and sounds logical or reasonable often runs afoul of the regulations.  I teach all my students to “know thy waste” which, simply put, means know everything about every waste produced.  Regardless of how you choose to handle it, the first question must always be “does it meet the definition of a hazardous waste?”

Once this is known, the next question is “what are my options for getting rid of it?”  On first look, this appears to be backwards, since the method of management will determine if it must be handled as a hazardous waste or may be managed less stringently.  The knowledge that it meets the definition of a hazardous waste should be made independently from the disposal or management method proposed.

In the case of Air Products and their “spent sulfuric acid” a $1.5 million dollar fine could have been avoided had they worked this waste stream through all the steps leading to a hazardous waste determination.  Unfortunately, the hazardous waste determination process is not very intuitive and ripe with many incorrect assumptions based on not understanding the difference between a chemical that is a product and one that is a waste.

There is absolutely no difference in the hazard or chemical property of the spent acid used by Agrifos when compared to new sulfuric acid.  Yes it is true that Air Product’s spent sulfuric acid also contained 2,4-DNT above 0.13 mg/L but that contaminant did not play any real part in the EPA’s enforcement effort.  In fact, had the 2,4-DNT been absent, the end result would still have been the same.

So if there is no difference between spent sulfuric acid and new sulfuric acid, why all the fuss?  Well the fuss is because by regulation they are different.  And therein lies the problem for most generators, it just doesn’t make sense.  Here Air Products has something that is seen as valuable by another company, why can’t they treat it like a product and not a waste?

There is a bit of back story missing that is not found on the EPA’s web site or in the Consent Decree that would provide the needed information to see if Air Products erred when they gave the spent acid to Agrifos  (I have sent an email asking for more info, and if it comes I’ll print their response.)  So, one must assume, based on the fact that there is a 1.5 million dollar fine and a Consent Decree, that the necessary requirements to manage it as “product” were not being met.

This being the case, it all came down to EPA’s contention that the sulfuric acid was spent.  Once that became their determination, Air Product’s method of sending the sulfuric acid to Agrifos became tantamount to illegal land disposal, the same as if they just up and dumped it on the ground.  That’s what they did, but that’s not what they did.

Huh?

And now you see the problem for companies like Air Products – this just does not make any sense when you look at it all the way through.
  • Does Agrifos make fertilizer?   Yes 
  • Does Agrifos use sulfuric acid to make their fertilizer?  Yes
  • Does the fertilizer go on the ground?  Yes
  • Is it legal for fertilizer made with sulfuric acid to go on the ground?   Yes 
  • Did Air Products provide sulfuric acid to Agrifos?   Yes
  • Did Agrifos use that sulfuric acid to make fertilizer?  Yes
  • Was that fertilizer made to be put on the ground?  Yes
Well that fertilizer - because it is designed to be placed on the ground - makes Air Products' sulfuric acid a hazardous waste.

Now wait just a cotton-picken minute there Pilgrim!  That makes no sense at all!

Yup, you’re right, which is why you can see how easily it was for Air Products to go down a path that created this big fat fine and the embarrassment of having their name plastered all over a Consent Decree for what the EPA (nicely enough) calls “hazardous waste mismanagement.”  They thought they were recycling, win for them win for Agrifos, a beneficial use of what would otherwise be a waste, which to most everyone looking at it would take it from waste status and put it in product status.  But it doesn't work that way.

Next post: Why the Solid Waste Determination is a really, really, really important step.